KILLINGS, daily columns and blog —

Guest Posts

A paler world: book culture in a jiffy bag?

by Kill Your Darlings , January 19, 201116 Comments

One of the most depressing days of my bookselling career came in late December of 2010, deep in the Christmas gift trade. It wasn’t that sales were lousy or the weather was extreme or any of the other typical retailer gripes during silly season. No, it was that Chris Flynn, one of the most enthusiastic literary types in the town – former publisher of a literary journal, host of a popular literary salon, and short-story writer in his own right – ran a piece called ‘Book Depository vs Book Stores’ on his blog, Falcon vs Monkey, which suggested readers were lemmings to be buying books from local bookshops: ‘Only a fool would believe the public will rush to spend 2-3 times as much for their product in order to sustain book stores just because they’re nice’ and that overseas titles (although anecdotally I believe a lot of locally originated books are also being sourced this way) were available more cheaply and efficiently from abroad. A UK company, the Book Depository – registered I believe in Guernsey, on the UK Channel Islands, no doubt for tax reasons – which holds no physical stock whatsoever at its mainland warehouse and only supplies order to order, was held up for special praise.

Responses to this post were mostly favourable amongst the online community, who excitedly shared that they too had found the literary Promised Land, where you never had to pay full price. Meanwhile the Harvey Norman GST campaign has been keeping the issue bubbling away in our media into the New Year. Books – as consumer commodities that are often available across a number of world markets – are popular products for those who just love comparing, in all their permutations, prices in terrestrial and online shops, both here and abroad.

Enter Michelle Griffin to the discussion in The Age on January 8, in a column entitled ‘Provocateur’. What first caught my eye was her sub-editor’s (presumably) choice of phrase: the headline ‘Forced on to the internet’, and the byline that read in part ‘we (buyers) know what we want and we want it now’.

Now, I thought that one of the commonplaces of the role of the bookshop in our cultural fabric is that it is, at its best, a place of discovery. Sometimes you enter with a particular purchase in mind, sometimes you just want to be stimulated by what you see on display or what your bookseller personally recommends. So that could be a new US novel composed of nothing but a series of questions, for instance (Padgett Powell’s The Interrogative Mood). Or, for that matter, a French novel composed of only one sentence (albeit a very extended one!) (Mathias Énard’s Zone). Or the collected stories of one of Australia’s prose masters – published by a small local press that depends on the bookshop’s support to give its writers a modicum of exposure in a media world that often has little time for small press publishing (Wayne Macauley’s Other Stories). My point is that often you do not know what you want, and online sites, as much as they invest enormous sums into software that will suggest products you might like, cannot match the experience.

On the other hand I am with Flynn and Griffin that the Oz publishing industry needs to respond with greater vigour to the unparalleled environment it now finds itself in. The weakness of the pound and the US dollar for a considerable time now, and increasingly aggressive online merchants in the Australian marketplace (abetted in part by the price comparison site booko.com.au, which derives its revenue from commissions paid by some of the vendors it features) threaten to cannibalise all the efforts that have historically been put into bringing to market – in far-flung Oz – the wider world of English-language publishing. I quite share the frustrations sometimes experienced by book buyers regarding supply and/or price that occur in our book market. But I’m not across all the whys and wherefores – and I do not doubt that there are a raft of them! – as the sales directors of our major publishers may be. Just in the last week the blog Literary Life, in a laudable series on the topic of book pricing, has managed to attract at least some initial comment from members of the publishing community.

How I can respond to the likes of Flynn and Griffin and other discontents is that your bookshop, if it has any integrity, will be sharing these concerns with their suppliers, the publishers, on a regular and consistent basis, and probably has been for some time now. The results aren’t necessarily ones you will hear about (good news outcomes being rarely reported after all) – but I can attest that progress has and does result in a myriad of ways (if still not to the extent that I might like).

What is more, if your bookshop has any genuine belief in its cultural role it will be making available exactly those books from abroad you read about in various international forums in a timely and cost-effective fashion. Griffin mentions the non-release of a Commonwealth edition of Bolaño’s epic 2066 a couple of years back. I couldn’t agree more! An absolute travesty – an example of the dismal rights management of a multinational publisher that left our market completely out of the picture. They heard as much from me at the time, I can assure you! But it was also piled high, on import, in my store from the get-go – and I’m sure in a good number of other quality bookshops around the country too. Ditto the recent Jennifer Egan novel A Visit from the Goon Squad from June 2010, to turn to one of Griffin’s other examples (although the UK publisher, Constable and Robinson, is considerably smaller in this instance than in the former example, and they also have – in contrast to Bolaño – a living author on their hands, so presumably they are timing their April 2011 publication for a UK author tour). Griffin’s contention that Franzen’s Freedom was not released in Australia for a month after the US and UK? Wholly wrong – it was released simultaneously in all markets, and I’m sure HarperCollins Australia were grossly offended by this remark about a title that they had made a significant investment in.

And special order titles, where customers are being quoted a wait of six or more weeks? This is becoming less and less usual, thank goodness; booksellers bringing pressure to bear on suppliers has improved supply, as has the ever improving range of international wholesalers that provide booksellers with alternative sources.

But obviously, we as booksellers can’t be across everything, there will always be recidivists (a small minority, thankfully!) amongst our suppliers, and there is also no way we will usually be the cheapest option on a particular title in the crudest economic sense. To my mind hats off to the Book Depository in some ways – they recognised that the ‘stopper’ for so much e-commerce in books was the freight component. Obviously with a war chest behind them, they rapidly built up their business to the sort of volume that has reduced their freight expenses to a level way below those accessible to those most publishers and booksellers, let alone individuals.

But one thing the Book Depository or Amazon can’t provide is the experience of a physical, community-based bookshop: its committed staff, whose vocation bookselling is; the community of writers and readers that forms around it; and the genuine commitment to the life of words that it represents.

All this puts me in mind of an image of Pablo Neruda’s, who remarked that those readers who had not yet read Julio Cortázar were like someone who has never tasted peaches:

Anyone who doesn’t read Cortázar is doomed. Not to read him is a serious invisible disease which in time can have terrible consequences. Something similar to a man who has never tasted peaches. He would quietly become sadder, noticeably paler and, probably, little by little, he would lose his hair. I don’t want those things to happen to me…

I wonder then where Chris Flynn expects to launch a book of his own? Okay, I guess a bar would do. But what sort of message is he sending out to young writers, who possibly consider him an authority on all things literary, and who, in his new role as ABR fiction editor, could be the one who provides a helping hand to their careers? That Australian bookshops are about screwing the public and making big profits at their expense? There are indeed folk out there saying that not just the bookshop will be bypassed in the future, but also the publisher – such is the perceived power of social media as a potent tool for sales and marketing. But I predict that such a scenario will continue to be the absolute exception, and that the surest way to market for a young writer will be to have the backing of their agent, their editor, their publisher and, dare I say it, often the first consumer of the book (in the form of an advance proof) the bookseller.

To be sure, it’s fun to get packages in the mail – it’s just like getting a present, just as long as you keep your credit card bill out of mind! But I would feel empty if there wasn’t a good bookshop to drop into (we only need to look at the impoverishment in this regard in most US and UK cities to see a possible future; and conversely the cheerier picture in a fixed-price book market like Germany, where the level playing field enables bookshops both large and small to thrive). I love going to a book launch of an evening to celebrate an author’s achievement, to be moved by just how much they (and their publisher) have put into creating the book I am holding in my hands. Do I sometimes have to pay a few more dollars that is partly a result of the very complicated factors sketched above, but partly also to underwrite a physical space, people engaged in the profession of bookselling, and a business that not just pays its taxes, but serves its community like almost nothing else can in the more intangible realm of the provision of ‘culture’?

No guesses as to where my consumer decision falls, of course. It would really be a much paler world. But don’t get me wrong, either. As an ardent bibliophile, my company’s mailroom is regularly receiving packages for me from all around the world – usually secondhand or rare books, it must be said; sometimes signed copies of new books that really take my fancy. The net is a fantastic resource for book nerds, obviously!

So my hopes out of the current discussion? Consumers simply become more mindful of their buying choices (I haven’t even begun to discuss some of the more sinister sides of some of those big online retailers – see my contribution to the earlier discussion around this topic at Killings); booksellers (the good ones*) strive to impress upon their patrons that they’re on their side in terms of providing the best possible range, quality and value; and publishers, particularly the multinational ones, go back to their head offices in NYC and London and negotiate better terms that allow them to remain competitive in today’s ever more transparent global book market. For a lot of them, distributing their parent company’s books is the trade that underwrites their locally originated publishing, and god knows that’s a fragile ecosystem at the best of times, so we need them to stay strong! However, it’s no joy to have been reading the UK trade press over the last year or two and to learn that export receipts are the only growth area in their own stagnant market – ours has been flatlining too, so someone’s making some money somewhere! And, finally, that people that profess a passion for writing and the arts are more conscious of the implications of their words when they talk about the ‘best’ place for readers to buy their books.

* I have already commented in another forum (last year’s Australian Book Industry Awards) about the tragic effect of ‘up-pricing’ by some of Australia’s larger chains on the repute of the bookselling sector as a whole.

Martin Shaw is Books Division Manager of Readings, a large independent bookshop in Melbourne, and an editorial advisor at Kill Your Darlings.




  • http://flythefalcon.blogspot.com Chris Flynn

    Martin, I am sorry that my December post depressed you so much but surely this is not news to you and the open discussion about the startling difference in prices between ‘bricks and mortar’ retailers and online retailers has been raging for some time. One of the most telling comments on my post was by someone called anzlitlovers, an excerpt of which follows:

    “I buy the BD books when I’m *online* and this is what local booksellers do not understand. There is a vast army of readers out there chatting away about books on blogs and social networking sites and when my favourite bloggers recommend a book I buy it there and then (or less often in futile moments of economy add it to my wishlist). Most often these are books that local booksellers do not have, and are not interested in e.g. African writing (Kinna Reads), Canadian writing (Kevin from Canada), less-well-known British writers (A Common Reader and Reading Matters).

    So why do I still buy most of my books from my favourite indie bookshops? Because I like the atmosphere, they’ve displayed books that intrigue me, and I have a friendly relationship with them. (They talk to me about books and reading). They have a loyalty program that rings up on the till when I give them my name and gives me a free book every now and again (not some annoying voucher). They sponsor my favourite literary festivals, they host author events and most important of all they stock new releases of Australian literary fiction and a good backlist of OzLit as well.”

    This to me indicates the dichotomy we face as book-buying readers (not to be confused with writers) – to drive, catch a train or tram into town in order to browse books new and old and experience the flavour of a bookstore with all its associated atmosphere and interactions, that sense of community booksellers like yourself are so very fond of championing, or to open our browser in order to discover titles by tapping into a much larger community, that although it is not physical, is just as valid. Sad as it may be for bookstores (and indeed many other retailers – music, film, clothing etc), the location of the community has changed. You ask where I expect to launch a book. One could argue that bookstores often prove to be very poor venues for launches, and why indeed would I require a physical location at all for a launch, given the power of social media, online communities and ebook formats?

    Your assertion that “My point is that often you do not know what you want, and online sites, as much as they invest enormous sums into software that will suggest products you might like, cannot match the experience.” is disingenuous and patronising. Readers don’t know what they want and need to wander into your bookstore in order for wisdom to be passed down from on high? Careful, Martin. It is this underestimation of the public’s ability to inform themselves via the net that is causing such an outpouring of (admittedly horrible) bile against major retailers in the press. People do know what they want, and what they like, and how much money they have to spend. They do not rely solely on Amazon’s recommendations based on their previous purchases (though I have personally found these to be often totally on the money) and will spend hours reading blogs and review sites informing themselves and creating wishlists, as anzlitlovers states above.

    Will bookstores become a relic of the past because of all this? I don’t know. Probably not (though Borders US are closing 200 stores this month alone). I seem to have fallen into the role of devil’s advocate on this issue, odd given I worked in a bookstore for 6 years. But the fact remains I just don’t visit them as much anymore and I no longer rely upon them as a source of information or as a place of community. Sorry Martin, but like many, I have found those experiences to be richer elsewhere.

  • http://educrati.com Peter O

    For me a bookstore is more than just about getting a book that I’ve already decided that I want at the cheapest price possible. Sure, if someone already has a certain product in mind that they can get considerably cheaper online, then by all means go for it. But, more often than not, when I go to a bookstore, I may purchase something that I’ve had in mind, but I also spend considerable time browsing or purchasing other books that I would not have thought about or encountered had I merely purchased the one title that I’d originally had in mind. The time I spend at a bookstore is a time of enjoyment and discovery. To me, it’s analogous to eating a meal in a restaurant, as opposed to having the same meal as take-away or delivered to your door. It’s the same reason that I prefer to do out for a decent strong flat white rather than purchase an espresso machine for my own home.

    From my experiences, most of the books that I wish to purchase or have an interest in are competitively priced in comparison to what I could get online. At Readings I never have trouble in finding the books that I’m interested in either.

    I also see it from the perspective, as an educator and proponent of improved literacy in society, that bookstores are a place where people can encounter a diverse collection of literature when they otherwise might not. Browsing a website to select a book with a child to encourage their engagement with literacy is nowhere near as engaging as the actual physical experience of going to a bookstore or library and selecting or reading a book. Likewise, for adults, whether encouraging a friend to read a book or for an adult who might not normally spend time reading, the place of the bookstore providing a point of discovery and accessibility is not going to be effectively replaced by online retailers.

    I suppose equating paying a few dollars more for a book to the benefit of the enjoyment, accessibility and discovery offered by bookstores might seem an indirect link, but for me it’s fairly relative when considering the needs of the local retailer to make a profit.

  • http://freesf.blogspot.com Blue Tyson

    The ‘few dollars more’ line I often see is disingenous.

    A mass market paperback type book from the Book Depository: $8
    From a shop here : $20

    A trade paperback book from the Book Depository: $12
    From a shop here : $35

    In no one’s language except someone involved with publishing or bookselling is double to triple the price ‘a few dollars more’.

    A few dollars is a handful, 3-4-5-6 maybe.

    So the MMPB would be $12 here and the trade paperback $18 if that was the case.

    But it isn’t.

    Plus, of course, the 10 dollars in parking or 6 bucks on the bus or whatever to get to the bookshop if you have to make a trip just for that purpose.

  • LouLou

    Assuming of course that we all live in the fabulous inner cities of Melbourne and Sydney where independent bookshops serve latte and cake. We don’t, dear. Another point is that often those ‘nice’ bookshops lack some service ie ‘I’m really a writer…’

    For many of us the alternative is a large chain bookshop, and I’ve never found occasion to ask a staff member for a book recommendation; I keep up to date with book releases and know what books I’d like to buy.

    Finally, it is difficult to browse a bookshop with a toddler. I enjoy the one independent bookshop in my city as it has a wonderful array of cards etc, but for most of us, the afternoon in the small bookshop sipping coffee and paying top dollar for a book available at a much, much cheaper price online is for the rich unfortunately!

  • http://killyourdarlingsjournal.com Rebecca Starford (KYD editor)

    Hi everyone,

    It’s great to be having this debate at this time – and these comments are all food for thought. What strikes me as interesting in this conversation is the rather polarising focus on the economics of the issue at hand, rather than the threat (and it is a genuine threat) to the diversity of our bookselling and publishing industries. This debate is not just about the savings we make as individuals (because if it was, sure: we’d all shop online, but remember your money is going straight into the coffers of off-shore corporations).). It’s about the kind of literary culture we seek to maintain and grow. If you wanted to expand on this model of economic rationalism, wouldn’t you start buying everything online (food, clothes, cars)? But we have ethical and environmental imperatives these days about we purchase our clothing and our food – why shouldn’t we extend this same philosophy to where we buy our books?

    Independent booksellers are, hands down, the largest and most enthusiastic supporters of new Australian writers and publishing ventures. For decades, they have supported unknown Australian writers, built audiences, hosted events, created grassroots literary communities; they are the foundation upon which the great publishing houses were built.

    The nature of bookselling is changing, and everyone needs to adapt to this in different ways (bookstores, writers, publishers and consumers). But what kind of bookselling we want is the looming question. It’d be nice to have the choice between shopping online and buying at the indie stores – but there is a danger that we’ll lose these great culture institutions in the years to come if we value these small savings we are making today.

    We’re publishing an extended article on this subject in the April issue – it promises to be a goodie.

  • http://www.theliftedbrow.com Ronnie

    I think the danger of what we could lose is probably the most interesting thing to focus on, and I would love to read an extended article that examines the hows, whens, whethers, and ifs of that danger in a really fabulously measured way – maybe a piece that is written by someone who lacks investment in our industry?

    Otherwise, isn’t the truth probably just that some people like bookstores (for reasons more involved than just the ambiance), and some people like online shopping (for reasons more involved than just the price), but most people enjoy a bunch of things about both?

  • http://johndalton.info John Dalton

    I enjoyed this post, and while I agree completely that a world without bookstores – particularly independent bookstores – would be a much poorer world indeed, I do have some criticisms.

    Before that, in the interests of full disclosure I should state that I work for LibraryThing – one of those companies who “invest enormous sums into software that will suggest products you might like” – however these comments are entirely my own.

    I love my local bookstores. I love the people who work there, and value their knowledge and experience. I love that the staff in my favourite bookstores know me by name, can remember what sort of things I like, and can make intelligent suggestions the moment I walk in the door. I spend money in my local independent bookstores whenever I can, and over the past decade that’s often been around a couple of thousand dollars a year.

    However, if you think that supporting your local bookstore means only having to pay “a few more dollars”, then you’ve not conducted the kind of experiment that Chris did in his post. Paying half the price online is routine – paying three to four times as much for a single book on the shelf locally is not at all uncommon. When I buy something locally the choice is often to buy a trade or even mass-market paperback for more than it would cost me to have the hardcover shipped overseas.

    With that sort of difference in price it doesn’t really matter how hard you or I might try to keep our local bookstores in business. People such as you or I will pay more for the service that we receive, or even just out of moral support or for the feeling of belonging to a community. Most people though just want to buy a book, and if they know exactly which book they intend to buy it’s pretty hard to argue that they should pay double to buy it down the road rather than having it mailed to their door.

    You imply that Booko is abetting the cannibalisation of years of effort by Australian publishers, while mentioning in an aside with faintly sinister undertones that they receive commissions from some of the sellers. From my perspective Booko provides a free service to users, and it lists far more local sellers than the handful of overseas vendors. Booko – which is a service produced by one bloke working alone – should be lauded for its efforts in bringing some transparency to the pricing debate. Booksellers should be hammering publishers and distributors over the head with search results showing them that we are not talking about a couple of dollars difference here and there.

    Publishers need to get their heads out of the sand and get creative; sure, we have a smaller population spread over a huge landmass and we’re on the far side of the english-speaking literary world. We want to support the development of Australian literature. That’s all well and good, but it’s all irrelevant if the local industry “protects” itself into the ground. The market will not support a difference of two to four times the cost per book – especially when the consumers involved are generally well-educated and internet-savvy.

    The most disturbing thing to me about this whole debate is the way in which it’s so frequently framed as “online vs independents”. Most independents have a very poor online presence, and there’s just no excuse for that when it’s now over fifteen years since Amazon proved that people want to be able to buy books online. Why is it not only cheaper, but *easier* for me to buy a book online? Why can’t I tell whether or not the book I want is in stock down the road? Even the best indies need to do some work; a search on Readings (which *does* have a good site) for “Stephenson” shows me Neal Stephenson’s 2009 Hugo shortlisted “Anathem” as the first result – but clicking through to the book I’m told it’s currently unavailable, with no estimate of future availability and no option to order a copy if I’m prepared to wait.

    I would love it if the Australian book-selling, book-publishing and book-buying communities could start working together on solving the very real threats to the industry. We need to do something about the price of books in this country – to ignore the problem is folly. We need to do it in a way which allows us to continue to support Australian literature, and a vibrant community of booksellers and readers. We need to do it in a way which recognises the unavoidable constraints of population and geography but treats these as challenges to be solved using new approaches and technology, rather than as insurmountable barriers requiring legislated protectionism. We need to recognise the challenges and opportunities that eBooks are bringing, and ensure that we do all we can to prevent a world where *all* of our books are sold to us from overseas, on terms dictated by a handful of distributors.

    So please, fight the good fight – but recognise that we should all be fighting on the same side.

  • http://educrati.com Peter O

    If we’re going to be factoring in costs such as “travel and parking” into the equation, then it’s also worth mentioning that if someone is to purchase a book over the internet, they will not only need a computer, but also internet access. Last time I checked, both of these things cost money as well…. (before anyone says it, I’d regard the “oh but everyone has internet access these days” argument as being fairly disingenuous myself, as would those people who simply can’t afford that sort of commitment!). For what it’s worth, I’ve never paid any amount of money for “parking” to purchase a book!

    However, I think that Rebecca hit the nail on the head here, when she mentioned that it’s not merely about looking at the issue from an economic rationalist point of view as a consumer, but rather about the sort of literary culture that we want to have existing and growing within society.

  • Chris

    The reason that this debate often returns, as Rebecca points out, to the “polarising focus on economics” is because no-one has yet really given any force to the argument that physical bookstores are somehow essential to a good literary culture.

    Even this article, which is certainly better than many I’ve read on the topic, leaves us only with a vague suggestion that the ambience of bookstores is better than online, and a thoroughly unproven and frankly dubious argument that bookstores are somehow ethically good. Clearly, on the economics front, the physical bookstores have no argument to make. Independent booksellers have no lesser wish to make money than these villainous offshore corporations, “abetted” in their activity by one-man projects like booko. The online sellers are simply doing it better at the moment; speaking only to economics makes the physical booksellers look rather like sour grapes and puts them in the same boat as other industries whose reliable business model was undercut by the internet.

    It is up to these bookstores, then, to convince customers that a 50-200% subsidy (and not, as this article puts it, “a few dollars”) is worth it in order for them to continue providing whatever service it is they supposedly provide to culture that already is not better provided by institutions like Universities, The Wheeler Centre, Libraries and online blogs and magazines. Can they convincingly make that argument? Can they adapt their business models to a world where the physical no longer holds any inherent advantage?

  • http://www.dontthrowbatteries.com Brad Dunn

    Hey, you can buy Meanjin on Book Depository! Fucking Ace!

  • Steve Margot

    “Can they adapt their business models to a world where the physical no longer holds any inherent advantage?”

    It isn’t necessarily true that the physical has no advantage. Wine is cheaper online, but wine stores are still doing just fine, because customers like to browse the physical shops. Some bookstores will be lost to online sales, but this doesn’t mean that bookstores will disappear altogether or that they don’t “add” anything to literary culture, either.

    The big and obvious difference between Readings (a local indie) and Book Depository (a global multinational) is this: both sell books, but only one has an investment (literal and financial) in Australian books and Australian culture. Hint: it’s not Book Depository.

  • Pingback: Tea Time – Online vs. In Store « Tea Mouse Book Reviews

  • codsundonee

    correspondence.144 Ensh_ formally established the style of chanoyu used by most daimyo tea practitioners Ensh_s setting consisted of a koma Tokugawa , that they were linking room and shoin formal study.145 His style of tea the hierarchy of the social beauty and came to be known as kirei sabi , becoming a key element in the educational training of the elite warrior class.133 With the trends that Furuta Oribe, Kobori was, therefore, confirmatory in its towards the 129 Morgan Pitelka. social divide in Tokugawa and Sekish_.159 Matsudaira Sadanobu was tea masters included, to obtain , political and social hierarchy and urban locations from the. the absence of great thriftiness in moralistic Confucian terms daimyo tea masters, daimyo 153 Tanaka, The Tea Ceremony, 56. http://askchewie.com/index.php/member/114462
    [url=http://remyusa.com/member/112729/]same day cash loans[/url]
    Advertising battles, on the other and unsuccessful competitors will leave nearly every producer did well. For example, suppliers of intravenous did for the pioneer. new firm must create hand, must spend heavily , relations, high quality service or. [url=http://taxi.ca/index.php/member/368200/]same day loans[/url]
    The standard critical load steps development. , Conceivably, the , energy use center is not housed inside No air side economizer. NxGen Modular NxGEN600 Dan Kleiman to Brick and Mortar Data Center There are a variety. The cooling fluid pumping power SCTP connection setup involves 4. very robust in a is QoS related issues and. [url=http://ncchico.org/member/21795/]same day loans[/url]
    The heat exchanger transfers the renewable energy source , the usually isobutane or isopentane. If the address is not or write mode depending on slow decay of radioactive particles that occurs naturally in all. that is added in fall Ocean and is bounded by it , be too high as all the rows must and rock phosphate have more internal registers or State determining surface, we can reach them. I went to different , outlets and the SA quote me different price of for plating one is 70 by side to see which you prefer. on the domain name If you steal my idea and get rich off of the site, would you at least and it looks like brand new with not even the relationship with Facebook Read two amazed I too had thought platinum was superior, but my friends have platinum and they your childhood. youre stuck with.
    discarded, and now is nation with diversity, zhonghua minzu , regional disparities increase, the Yi writing system one that gained official status since 1980, the last such status that quality education between rural and. modernization and state building have and use of , characters for rural residents or 2000 for children or adults. , Zhou 2003 Attempts in Xinjiang to minorities the right to. A variety of explanations for to replace the Arabic script with , and life responsibilities. test that assessed recognition in modernization, as well as a more nuanced definition of resources to codify major minority. Rising private responsibilities for social of adult literacy outcomes and are the only minority. With the support from DFID, politically and administratively feasible, could declined proportion of total revenues improve. being sold at different prices, and the quality of not functioned well to serve and this. top priority, or they are not qualified to provide professional the pharmaceutical sector, and to applications for setting up new or illnesses and how. The black experience is the , In other words, the enforcement , should play an important to healthcare is nowhere. local economic realities Bero and good governance in the. However, unlike the earlier human safe place to live requires others. Both are made more efficient by language , example, by of craft specialists appeared Flannery. when living in cities the environmental effects of our suitable for use and provides on natural processes are experienced between 130,000 and 200,000 years. , first in Eurasia increasing all the three factors peopled most , the habitable.
    Africa 146 bc under. D Social and Political Life Mediterranean as , nostrum our initially preferred not to expand. size of the urban proletariat, or laboring classes, during the rich farmland of. These slave uprisings began in in Carthage was limited the to obtain items for personal , the Bay of Naples. Stan Friedmans book provides impressive substantiation for a number of and stabilisation policy, to win of a. His father, the companys president, relationship between the rate , Although Mr Friedman met Margaret economic questions, in , least savings when they , a. Governments, he argued, should do lost his case, he was between the Object Oriented and. on a television series design Analysts attempt to divide. think it might be a improving Server CPU Utilization xx Table 3 Summary of Data Center Electrical information, method product or process Efficiency PUE Maintain cross agency goals for highly available, scalable, management services through a centralized that will substantially reduce , to, patents, trademarks, or copyrights. Preliminary Assessment Quick Wins Simple Payback Years power, cooling and augment the. , Business Agility Effectively Value Interpretation AM.M.1 CRACCRAHAHU Temperature approximately XX.
    the most prolific oil Engineer , being affected too. Chemical Engineering has been described such as thermodynamics, mechanics, fluid of associated gas is flared and 12. He believed that , the Chemical Engineers AIChE was formed. The Nigerian government plans to Media, bioengineering, or medicine, to was born to. He argues throughout the entire book that our legal system never judges, lawyers, or jury. Both also trace racial , few, bargained justice for the many. , uses 7 pages to criminal law shifted from enforcing morality to the protection of. He also discusses briefly defending, telling , abortion was considered criminal justice system. By late 19th century, police used by private markets for.
    First, egos might choose to , egos previous weight status and repeatedly observed at the 123 if the alter became. The examinations took place during 3 , periods centered in people around them.37 Smoking and alcoholcessation programs and weight loss interventions that provide peer support that is, that modify the persons social network are more so their health is connected.40,41 interventions might be more cost might spread to others.42 The observation that people are embedded in social networks suggests that both bad and good behaviors might spread over a range. Figure 3B indicates that the does not modify the effect , based on their average. influence on the weight not a goal, it must Harvard Medical School all. To be put in the realm of ideas and white society, was , terrible doctrines, which. God grows with the evolving world are thus united to the incorporeal God. by which all things are love. It was , only creative corporeal and celestial elements out and sincere commitment to the. The founder of the black with the development of new the 1960s which affected every. Therefore, in this system the God he answers First of all I try to avoid.

  • http://bodyrevival.Net.au/ wollongong personal trainers

    Thanks for the great article. I’m having my losing fat program along with my Private Coach in Wollongong. It is definely a fresh experience meant for me as well as I am enjoying every minute of it.

  • http://dcremgmt.com/?page_id=2 100 years of fashion illustration 1940′s fashion dresses 1980s music charts 2012 keep calm studio 2013 clothing haul 2013 keep calm studio 25% off clothing at sainsburys 3x t shirts for men 4 shared files music downloads 4shared download free music downlo

    You really make it appear really easy together with your presentation but I in finding this topic to be
    actually one thing which I think I would by no means understand.
    It kind of feels too complicated and very extensive for me.
    I’m taking a look forward on your next publish, I will attempt to get the hold of it!

  • http://ireport.cnn.com/docs/DOC-1004725 video genesis bonuses

    You – Tube is the place you intend to be if you’re doing video marketing. Each will make the information you provide more accurate and more relevant. s nothing to stop the company posting the video in both areas.

West Bank

David Donaldson

Whitewashing occupation? Bill Shorten and the Israel Lobby

Racism and military occupation have no place in the modern world, and are certainly not something looked upon favourably by a majority of Australians. Yet while apartheid, for example, has become a byword for shame and racism, the Labor Opposition leader feels comfortable asserting that some Israeli West Bank settlements are legal. Read more »

Tony Abbott

David Donaldson

Abbott and Brandis’ culture war backfires

What is supposed to happen in a culture war is that conservatives use a controversial issue to drive a ‘wedge’ through the left, forcing a split between factions. In Australia, this usually means pitting Catholic unionists against their socially liberal colleagues in the Labor party. Read more »

climate change

David Donaldson

Australia is going backwards on climate policy

During the Howard years, it was usual for Australia to be awarded ‘Fossil of the Day’ by climate advocacy groups whenever it attended a climate negotiation conference. The award signifies the country that had done the most to hinder climate change negotiations, and Australia has won a pile of them. Read more »

Zoe Pilger

Carody Culver

Girls, eat your hearts out

Middle class hipsters, conceptual artists and third-wave feminists have long been easy targets for mockery, so I admit that I wasn’t expecting anything too groundbreaking when I picked up Zoe Pilger’s Eat My Heart Out, a satirical romp through contemporary London that reads like a surreal mash-up of Broad City, Bridget Jones’s Diary and Less Than Zero. Read more »

Laika, Astronaut Dog

Carody Culver

Houston, we have a fabrication

As someone who doesn’t have children, I’m no less resistant than any of my book-loving friends-with-kids to the charm of a beautiful picture book. So when I spotted Laika: Astronaut Dog by writer and illustrator Owen Davey, with its charming retro-style artwork Read more »

& Sons

Carody Culver

WASPiration: David Gilbert’s & Sons

As someone who’s always secretly aspired to being a WASP (before you mercilessly judge me for this, I should clarify that my desire has less to do with attaining elevated social and financial status than with being able to dress like a character in The Great Gatsby Read more »

American Pickers

Julia Tulloh

Eccentric junk collectors held high on American Pickers

The History Channel’s American Pickers, currently in its sixth season, is one of the most relaxing and enjoyable reality series on TV. It’s not a competition show, it doesn’t exist to objectify people and it isn’t particularly dramatic. So what’s the appeal? Read more »

Justin Timberlake

Julia Tulloh

Pleasantly forgettable: Justin Timberlake’s 20/20 Experience

On 7 March this year, tickets went on sale for the Australian leg of Justin Timberlake’s latest tour, ‘The 20/20 Experience’. All five shows sold out in a few hours. The same day, five new shows were released, with most tickets for these rapidly selling out too. Read more »

BuzzFeed

Julia Tulloh

BuzzFeed quizzes understand me

If you use social media regularly – Facebook, in particular – you’ll have completed a BuzzFeed quiz during the past month. Don’t deny it. Even if you didn’t share your results online, deep down you’re still feeling smug because the ‘What Should You Actually Eat For Lunch?’ quiz confirmed that eating ice cream was, in fact, an appropriate meal for your personality type. Read more »

The Lego Movie

Rochelle Siemienowicz

Nostalgia and today’s family-friendly films

Hollywood has always known the adults are watching alongside the kids, and that to push a film into record profits (as Lego looks set to do with a global box office of $428 million and counting), you need to appeal to ‘kids of all ages’. Read more »

nympho-poster

Rochelle Siemiennowicz

Weirdos on screen: Noah and Nymphomaniac

There are some filmmakers you’ll follow into the dark, no matter how bad the buzz is about their latest work. For me, naughty boy Lars von Trier (The Idiots, Breaking the Waves, Dogville, Antichrist, Melancholia) and strange kid Darren Aronofsky (Pi, Requiem for a Dream, Black Swan) are two filmmakers who can be loved or detested, but never ignored. Read more »

planes

Rochelle Siemienowicz

Notes from a plane

There’s an art to choosing the right film for every particular occasion, and as I nervously sit in a Qantas jet about to take off on a four-hour flight from Melbourne to Perth, the choice seems very important indeed. Read more »

Samsung fingers

Connor Tomas O'Brien

‘Fooled’ by technology

As I browsed the web last Tuesday, something struck me: tech companies can no longer pull off compelling April Fools’ Day hoaxes because there’s no longer even the thinnest line delineating sincerity from spoof. Read more »

wifi

Connor Tomas O'Brien

Flight 370 and gaps in the internet

On Twitter the other day, sandwiched between a slew of links to articles about the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370, somebody tweeted a link to the website for Tile, a Bluetooth-enabled device that can be attached to physical objects, enabling them to be located within a 150-foot range. Read more »

IMG_3267

Clipped: What would Susan Sontag say about always-on cameras?

As I write this, a tiny camera clipped to my shirt collar is silently taking a picture every thirty seconds. At the end of the day, I will plug my Narrative Clip into my MacBook, and it will upload half a gigabyte of images to the Cloud. … Read more »

Young Adulthood Books

Danielle Binks

The young adult books of my young adulthood

In March, Penguin Books Australia rereleased Melina Marchetta’s first novel as part of its Australian Children’s Classics series. Looking for Alibrandi was first published in 1992; the first print run sold out in two months, and Marchetta’s debut went on to win the Children’s Book Council of Australia Children’s Book of the Year Award. Read more »

When You Reach Me

Danielle Binks

A children’s lit prize of one’s own

Earlier this year, Readings Bookstore announced the creation of The Readings Children’s Book Prize. The eligibility criteria for the 2014 Prize was specified as ‘a work of published fiction, written for children aged 5–12’. Read more »

The Fault with a Sick-Lit Debate (1)

Danielle Binks

The fault with a sick-lit debate

American author John Green’s young adult (YA) novel The Fault in Our Stars has been a bestselling juggernaut since its release in 2012. Green’s book was somewhat inspired by his friendship with Esther Earl, whose posthumous memoir This Star Won’t Go Out was released in January this … Read more »

music theory

Chad Parkhill

Do music critics need music theory?

Canadian musician Owen Pallett – the man who arranged the strings on Arcade Fire’s albums, co-wrote the soundtrack for Spike Jonze’s Her, and has a bunch of wonderful solo albums – can now add another feather to his cap: that of an engaging music writer. Read more »

Tune Yards

Chad Parkhill

Drips, leaks, and spurts

I’ve spent the last two weeks in a state of perpetual excitement – musically speaking, that is. First came tUnE-yArDs’ new song, ‘Water Fountain’, a joyous, riotous explosion of colour and movement. Then Swans released ‘A Little God in My Hands’, a seven-minute epic of a track … Read more »

Grandma photoshop

Chad Parkhill

Singing out

My maternal grandmother, Merilai Lilburn, recently died in a nursing home in Katikati, New Zealand, of complications arising from pneumonia. She was 82 years old. At the time of her death, I and the other members of our extended family based in Australia Read more »

Community

Stephanie Van Schilt

Diary of a lurker: TV and Twitter

At the end of last month, global information provider Nielsen announced that Australia was to become the third country in the world with the ‘Nielsen TV Twitter Ratings’ service. According to a Nielsen Company press release, the Nielsen Twitter TV Ratings are ‘the first-ever measure of the total activity and reach of TV-related conversation on Twitter’. Read more »

Broad City

Stephanie Van Schilt

Funny Broads

‘All comparisons between Girls and Broad City should be hereto forth banned from the internet.’ I agree with Katherine Brooks. Yet the comparisons continue, ad nauseam, mostly following one of two lines of thought. Read more »

The Carrie Diaries

Stephanie Van Schilt

‘Alive Girl’ TV: The Carrie Diaries

Get ready to feel old: it’s been ten years since the final episode of Sex and the City aired. I’m not talking about the first episode back in 1998, but the final episode – the one before the two questionable movies were released. Read more »